Get in touch

Fill out this form and our team will respond as soon as we can, alternatively email us at mail@icepanel.io.

Back to all blogs

Comparison - IcePanel vs Miro

Comparing IcePanel and Miro for designing software architecture

comparisondiagrammingsoftware architecture
10 Dec 2024
Blog hero image

⚡ TL;DR

🆚 Comparing IcePanel with Miro

IcePanel is a collaborative diagramming and modelling tool based on the C4 model. It’s best for consistently mapping software systems across teams for technical and non-technical audiences. With IcePanel, you can create hierarchical diagrams with a simple set of abstractions and interactive user journeys with Flows.

Miro is a general-purpose whiteboarding tool that helps teams create and collaborate on various activities, from ideation to planning. With Miro, you can draw flow charts, UML, journey maps, and mind maps in real-time with your team.

So, which tool is right for you? In this article, we’ll compare them for documenting software architecture.

Audience

Feature IcePanel Miro
Primary Users Software architects and developers Product managers, designers, marketers, business analysts, and developers
Secondary Users Product managers, business analysts, and other non-technical audiences can view and comment All team members

Use case

Feature IcePanel Miro
Primary Use Case Software architecture diagramming and modelling using the C4 model for complex systems Diagramming (flow charts, journey maps, UML, BPMN), brainstorming, and project planning

📝 Key diagramming features

Miro offers various templates for creating diagrams, such as flowcharts, mind maps, and customer journey maps. This includes software architecture-specific templates for UML and the C4 model. It’s a tool that can do many things but isn’t especially focused on software architecture diagrams. It’s a jack of all trades but a master none.

IcePanel is built to help teams create structured and detailed software architecture diagrams using the C4 model. It includes additional features to help maintain and communicate complex systems to different audiences. Since IcePanel is model-based and has a diagram hierarchy (read more about this here), it provides several benefits for representing software architecture.

In general, IcePanel is a more opinionated tool for documenting software architecture. There are less diagram types (only 3 in a hierarchy), a smaller set of abstractions (5 object types), and a single source of truth with a model. These ‘constraints’ remove a lot of the unnecessary complexity when it comes to diagram layout or formatting, instead allowing teams to focus on the actual design of their architecture.

Feature IcePanel Miro
Diagram types 3 zoomable C4 levels (context, container, component) General templates (UML, BPMN, journey maps), Mermaid diagrams
Model-based ✅ Yes 🔴 No
Ability to add icons ✅ 3000+ icons on all plans, plus custom icons ✅ Yes, on all plans
Shapes Fixed C4 shapes (actor, system, app, store, component) Basic and custom shapes for different notations (UML, BPMN, Data flows, etc.)
Text fields in canvas 🔴 No ✅ Yes
Connection types Single-direction, bi-direction Single-direction, bi-directional, no direction
Custom tags for objects ✅ Yes 🟡 Tags on sticky notes and cards only
Interactive user journeys ✅ Yes, with Flows 🔴 No. Interactive presentation mode and click-through prototypes only
Dependencies view ✅ Yes 🔴 No
Decision records (ADRs) ✅ Yes 🔴 No (templates only)
Custom pen tool 🔴 No ✅ Yes

👥 Collaboration

IcePanel and Miro enable teams to collaborate on diagrams with comments, share links, and different role types. Both tools are designed to be used across a team, helping drive alignment and clarity through visual artifacts.

Feature IcePanel Miro
Commenting 3 comment types with mentions. Free viewers can comment General commenting with mentioning
Share links Read-only links with password or SSO (Growth+) Edit, comment, and view links. Password protection on paid plans
Revision history and versioning Manual or scheduled versions, with revert Hourly versions kept 90 days, restored as a copy (paid)
Drafts Git-like drafts you can merge into the model 🔴 No
Embeds Embed interactive diagrams using iFrames Embed boards or specific frames as interactive iFrames
Viewers Viewers are free and unlimited on all plans Viewers or Guests are free and unlimited on Business and Enterprise plans

🔁 Importing and exporting

IcePanel and Miro support importing and exporting in multiple file formats. IcePanel focuses on structured model imports, including model as code with JSON and YAML. Both tools support exporting in several file formats, with some small differences (IcePanel exports PNG, which Miro doesn’t).

Feature IcePanel Miro
Importing JSON/YAML (model as code), Structurizr, Backstage, REST API Lucidchart, Visio, Draw.io, Mural, FigJam, and more (paid)
Exporting SVG, PNG, PDF, JSON, CSV, Structurizr, HTML, Markdown, LLMs.txt REST API JPG, SVG, PDF, CSV, board backup, REST API, save to Google Drive

🔒 Security

IcePanel and Miro are both SOC 2 Type II, ISO/IEC 27001, and GDPR compliant. SAML-based SSO is available on both IcePanel Growth and Miro Business plans. Miro’s also compliant with SOC3 and CCPA.

Feature IcePanel Miro
Viewers (read-only) ✅ Yes ✅ Yes
SSO ✅ Yes (available on Growth plans) ✅ Yes (Business and Enterprise plans)
SOC 2 Type II ✅ Yes ✅ Yes
GDPR ✅ Yes ✅ Yes
ISO/IEC 27001 ✅ Yes ✅ Yes
Data protection TLS 1.2 for transit and AES 256 at rest TLS 1.2+ in transit, encrypted at rest (bring-your-own-key on Enterprise)
Audit logs ✅ Yes (Scale plan) ✅ Yes (Enterprise plan)
SCIM 🔴 No ✅ Yes (Enterprise plan)
Data Residency US, or custom GCP regions on Scale+ EU by default. US, Australia, and Japan on Enterprise
Trust page https://trust.icepanel.io/ https://miro.com/trust/

💰 Pricing

Both IcePanel and Miro charge per editor on monthly or annual plans. IcePanel is more expensive than Miro, with architects and engineers being the primary editors.

Feature IcePanel Miro
Business pricing (monthly) $50/editor/mo $25/editor/mo
Business pricing (annual) $40/editor/mo $20/editor/mo (no tiered discounts)
Enterprise pricing Scale: $80/editor/mo annually (20+ editors). Enterprise: custom (50+) Custom pricing (minimum 30 seats)

🏁 To wrap up

If you’re looking for a tool to document your software architecture, IcePanel and Miro are two options you’ll likely consider. Miro can work if you’re looking for a general-purpose whiteboard for ideation and quick diagrams. If you mainly need throwaway software diagrams that won’t be referenced in the future, it may be enough.

However, IcePanel is a better fit if you’re looking for a specialized tool that excels in documenting software architecture consistently with a source of truth. Comparing these tools 1:1 is tricky because they solve different problems. There may be a world where you use both tools in your organization, depending on the use case and team.

📚 Resources

Tim

Get cool architecture news

Sign up for our free newsletter.

Stay chill

Get in touch

Fill out this form and our team will respond as soon as we can, alternatively email us at mail@icepanel.io.